[JoeGuardsman]

The one thing that I like about LotR is that you can actually choose unit formations. I can take my Gondor and make a sheild wall, turn a wing of a unit, assume a wedge or a square. Since it is free form you don't have to use formations but you really get to see the point of certain true to life maneuvers and formations in the game.
The other realish thing that I dont really like at times but is romantic in idea is the tending to need 6's to kill. 'cause really a trained soldier in heavy armor and a shield is going to be hard to break down. The horrible rugby match that can be cause by a couple of turns of bad luck is just a little much to handle some times.
I do agree with the Hero centric buisness. I've lost to Imrahil every time I've played him. He is a weinus.
As far as painting goes I really like the chance that LotR gives me. I have a real life picture of every model to attempt an recreate. That is a very fun challenge to me expecially after painting green and yellow High Elves or multi-colored Ogre Kingdoms.